Letter to the next Secretary of War
Document 1800Letter from James McHenry, former Secretary of War, to his successor. McHenry details the state of the Department and points out what needs immediate action. He discusses the state of Indian affairs, the need for a military academy, the establishment of a factory for small arms near Harper's Ferry, and other matters.
No human transcription currently available for this document.
This transcription was generated by machine using Anthropic's Claude Code (a mix of sonnet and opus models). It may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please verify against the document image. Learn more about our generative AI methodology.
War Department
[date obscured] 29 May 1800
Sir
On the table I have used, [strikethrough: while in] the Department of war, you will find a Packet inscribed "[strikethrough: letters to be referred to my successors] Mr Henry." [strikethrough: These] papers relate to several subjects which will require [strikethrough: and more] recommended to your serious deliberations. On all or most of [strikethrough: them] I have made some notes.
I take the liberty also to mention some measures I have taken, directions I have lately given, and [strikethrough: also] a few general objects of the Department which may require particular attention.
[strikethrough: For] Directions have been given to the Major Generals Hamilton & Pinckney, to issue orders and take measures, the most efficient, to ensure the discharge, on the 15th day of June next, of all such officers, non-commissioned officers and privates, as have heretofore been appointed, commissioned or raised, under and by virtue of "an act
carrying into effect, and all military articles, with every part of the army [strikethrough: to be discharged]. And to have forwarded [undecipherable: assessed], from the residue of the clothing for the [undecipherable] twelve Regiments, the full compliment of a Regiment of Infantry, one half to [undecipherable] the account at Savannah, the other half within the Department at Knoxville, Tennessee, subject to the orders of [strikethrough: Lieut] Colonel [undecipherable].
Also from the same residue, agreeably with directions to [undecipherable], to Natchez or Loftus Heights on the Mississippi, complete suits of Infantry clothing from forty one [undecipherable], twenty three musicians and five hundred and fifty three privates; and to Pittsburgh, to the address of Major [undecipherable] Class, complete suits of Infantry clothing for [undecipherable] three Serjeants, [undecipherable] musicians [undecipherable] and 703 privates. I have further advised Brigadier General Wilkinson of the quantity of clothing sent to the Mississippi and Pittsburgh and that it is expected he will cause the same to be divided into the parcels he may distribute for different garrisons or detachments on the Mississippi Frontiers
* And lest the residue of the new army clothing should not be found [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] sufficient, I have directed the quantity that may be and forwarded deficient to be provided out of the clothing public stores.
to augment the army of the United States and for other purposes" and the 9th Section of "an act for the better organizing of the troops of the United States and for other purposes" conformably to the express orders of the President. And the directions of the Commanding Generals to the Pay Master General have been enforced by me — to forward sufficient monies to the proper officers, to pay the officers and men within the purview of "an act supplementary to the act to suspend part of an act entitled "an act to augment the army of the United States, and for other purposes" passed the 14th instant, as well up to the 14th of June, when they are to be discharged, as the three months additional pay allowed by the 3d section of the last cited act, to every such discharged officer, non-commissioned officer and private respectively.
2d. To the Superintendants of Military Stores to take effectual measures, for securing and transporting through the agency of the Quarter Master General, to proper places of deposit, the residue of cloathing, tents,
and North Western [undecipherable: written] and advised the Quarter Master to have the parcels duly transported. I have also given similar information and advice to Lt. Col. [undecipherable: Butler] relative to the cloathing designed for the troops under his command. [undecipherable]
3. A sufficiency of new Cloathing, has [strikethrough: [undecipherable] to be] been cut out for the Regiments of Artillerists, and Engineers and alec [undecipherable] over the orders of the Secretary, respecting its distribution. Cloathing also has been cut out for the Infantry [strikethrough: [undecipherable] on the old establishment], but to what amount having received no report cannot be ascertained. It was a proposition of the General Officers, that the army cloathing should be cut out and sent to the respective corps and detachments, to be made up by the Taylors in each company, at the stated allowance by Law — believing that beneficial effects would result from its adoption, and the men certainly be better fitted.
4. In pursuance of the 2d Section
section of "an act for the better organizing of the troops of the United States and for other purposes" passed the 3d of March, 1799. By my directions, cloaths and other materials except buttons for cloathing the army, have been imported through the agency of Mr William Chancellor of Philadelphia, to the amount of [blank] dollars; and I have specially instructed the Superintendant of Military Stores, to attend to the preservation of this cloath. It will however in my opinion be proper, my successor in office should revisit these instructions, and from time to time ascertain that his orders are strictly attended to — otherwise this cloath, unavoidable in particular, may be greatly injured or totally destroyed by moths.
5. The Indian stipends engaged by treaties — have been directed to be procured assembled and forwarded, viz. those for the North Western Indians to Cincinnati, that for the Chickasaws to [undecipherable], that for the Cherokees to Tellico Block house — that for the Creeks to the Factory at Fort Wilkinson, that for the Choctaws & the [strikethrough: Natchez] [undecipherable: Natchez?] that for the Six Nations to Canandaigua —
6. It is especially and respectfully recommended to my successor, to make himself as soon as possible, minutely acquainted with the actual state of the Indian Superintendencies
and also with the system, which has been adopted and is now in execution for ameliorating the condition of the Indians, and keeping them at peace with and attached to the United States. I can not but flatter myself that the efficiency of this system, conceived by the late President, will not be impaired under the direction of my successor, having had its success much at heart, and leaving under its beneficial influence, that most numerous with time, the great body of Indians in all parts of the United States, who are [strikethrough: disposed] to the interest of our Country — friendly to each other — indisposed to war, and [strikethrough: rapidly] progressing in civilization. *(c)
7h. The Indian trading houses or Factories upon the Oconee and at Tellico, will also demand particular attention. The law for establishing them, contemplates, that the capital shall be employed, in such a manner as not to be reflected on the public, [undecipherable: refer] No Clos. The President has lately authorized, the sending an intelligent, confidential and disinterested person along the Western frontiers, to examine into the state, condition, kinds and mode of
+(6)
To aid this system a series of medals in silver & bronze have been procured from England with devices elegantly executed, emblematic of the progressive states of man from the Savage, to the earliest arts of civilized life. These were intended to be distributed, by the Superintendants as encouragements, to those of the Indians, who showed the greatest advances in raising cattle, the cultivation of their Lands, and the domestic manufactures of spinning and weaving. They are deposited in [strikethrough: four] boxes in the Bank of the U.S., except a few which are in a desk in the Secretary's room at the War Office — the key of [strikethrough: both] which will be left enclosed for my successor. I have taken to myself, [strikethrough: resolving to present] [strikethrough: [undecipherable] relative [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: the [undecipherable] of [undecipherable] Washington, and by children [undecipherable]] to cause to my [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: [undecipherable] and [undecipherable] of his [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] two of each of the three sets forming the series. wishing to preserve mere evidence of the benevolent intentions, of the administration of General Washington. towards the Indians, and
preserving, and distributing the public property in that quarter — he will also be especially charged to examine into, and report the state of the Factories, modes of conducting business at them, capacities and characters of the conductors.
2o. Early attention will be requisite to the execution of existing contracts for casting cannon within the United States. It is recommended that no person be permitted to inspect and prove cannon under said contracts, whose skill and integrity to not furnish a complete guarantee to the public against every improper influence.
9. It is recommended to my successor, to direct the Accountant for the Department, to proceed without delay, to the final settlement of the accounts of the Pay Master General, which has it is understood been delayed, under different pretexts, until the amount unsettled is seriously great, and to use the same conduct with respect to the accounts of all other public agents and contractors, it being my opinion, that the best security to the public against frauds and improper expenditures, will be found — in the practice of requiring every person charged with the public money, to settle his accounts for disbursement
at short and fixed periods.
10. With respect to the contingent expenses and extra compensation to officers for extra service, I have with regret to inform you, that a new principle lately set up by the Accountant, viz. "that whenever a person holds an office, to which the Laws has annexed pay and emoluments, he cannot be allowed extra compensation for extra services, except by Congress, and in virtue of an express law" has stagnated the discretion always heretofore used by the Secretary of War on such subjects. That as the Department is by its constitution, to be conducted in such manner as the President of the United States, shall order or instruct — I have referred this principle, with a few cases obstructed by it, to the President for his orders and instructions, but have not yet had the honor to receive them. In some reference, I stated the new principle to be in my conception, utterly incompatible with the good of the military service — inconsistent with all former practice during the Revolutionary war, and since in all the Departments, and calculated to paralyze the energies of the Executive throughout all branches [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] of the government.
11. The improvement of the corps of Artillerists and Engineers has been to me an object of much attention. I have attempted modifications of them, the attainment of a corps of Engineers, peculiarly indispensable to a country possessing few or none — and the establishment of a military academy, if these projects have not been successful, I flatter myself they have not been absolutely rejected. I will however observe, that the importance of the corps of Artillerists & Engineers, even as now arranged, must be too evident to need elucidation — but that unless the greatest care is taken, in filling up future vacancies, and to induce further improvements in them, they will prove, at yearly expense, without corresponding [strikethrough: great] and more of correspondent [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] [undecipherable: beneficial] advantages.
12. Will it be permitted to mention, that I have employed on the fortifications erecting at Baltimore, in the capacity of Engineer, a French Gentleman of the name of [undecipherable: Foncin], and that evidences of ability in his profession by correcting errors of much consequence, in the original plans of the works, as well as
rapidity in superintending and directing the progress induced me to raise the compensation he was first engaged at. This gentleman I would recommend to be continued in employ as heretofore — being much mistaken, if he will not be found, worthy of trust, competent to what he has undertaken, upright and unassuming in his conduct.
13. For the purpose of establishing an armory or manufacture of small arms, a site was selected on the Potomac, near Harpers ferry, particularly recommended by the late President, and the ground with certain buildings already erected on it, purchased. Progress has been made in this establishment, and the commencement of the fabrication of arms, has been some time made; much however yet remains to be done, to carry it to maturity, the completing of a canal begun and in considerable forwardness and the necessary buildings, at this armoury for the comfortable accommodation of the Superintendent &c. will demand your immediate and minute attention. Detachments from the troops, under the command of Major General Pinckney, have been from motives of economy employed in the canal. As however these men, must be withdrawn on the 14th of June next, the day fixed for disbanding the new army, it will be proper that seasonable ar-
rangements should be made, to supply their places, by hired labourers — or delay will be occasioned in completing an important establishment.
Major General Pinckney mentions in a letter to me, dated the 22 instant, [undecipherable: to the] limits in his cantonement (in the vicinity of the army) are well built and valuable; some person should be appointed to take charge of them as well as those on the hill. [undecipherable] find in my perhaps think it proper to apply the [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] of the materials of those huts, as not, but for the purposes towards the erection of the necessary buildings at the Armory.
14. Impressed with a conviction, that the cannon contemplated to be purchased by "an act to enable the President of the U.S. to procure cannon, arms, and ammunition, and for other purposes" passed the 4th of May, 1798 — were intended to be efficient, and the best adapted to different kinds of service, to which they must be applied — and knowing that the measures since have, nor any that can be taken, to procure cannon by purchase, for the use of the U.S. either by importation from abroad or manufacture at the different private founderies at home, could never insure, that at highest uniformity,
uniformity in modes, weight, caliber and consistency of metal necessary to the perfection, and full utility of the ordnance of every Country — also having a wise grounded expectation, that metal could be had in the U.S. adjacent to one of our national armories, superior to any that had been used, for the guns procured by purchase — and believing provision was made by the 3d section of the act cited, enabling to purchase foundaries in case such establishments, should be found necessary, — I wrote a letter to the Secretary of the Navy on the 20th of March last, proposing that, the two Departments should join in a representation to the President, recommending the purchase of a site for a cannon foundery, and of ore, the best adapted for ordnance, in exclusive propriety to the U.S. — and also a permanent national establishment for casting cannon and shot. I enclosed a report by Major Tousard, relative to some experiments made by him on a very local [undecipherable: type?], cast from metal, the ore of which is found near Harpers Ferry, and cursorily Touched
upon advantages I supposed to be peculiar to the site from its vicinity to a national armory, and added, that the lightness combined with strength, of [undecipherable] guns, which would probably be cast from this metal, seem to recommend it for those designed for ships, and to promise that the iron fabricated from it, would be very suitable for small arms. To this letter the Secretary of the Navy replied on the 7th of March last, expressing a decided opinion, that the U.S. ought to possess, one or more such establishments as the one proposed, a belief that the vicinity of Harpers Ferry on the Potomac was a very proper place for one such establishment — and a free consent that he be considered as joining in an application to the President recommending the measures proposed — suggesting however — that further experiments should be made on the ore in question, to ascertain precisely the expectations, that might be formed of it.
Further experiments being made and the results reported on the 26 & 30 April last by Major Tousard, on light guns cast from the same metal, and some necessary inquiries
made respecting the value of the land, and the wood and water on the proposed sites, as well as the title of the same — all of which have been communicated to the Secretary of the Navy. I on the 1st of May by a letter detailing as far as known to me, every circumstance, and enclosing every paper I was possessed of relative to the measure. solicited the Presidents direction whether the proposed site and ore should be purchased and a national foundary for casting cannon Shot and shells be then established.
The President answered as follows.
Philadelphia may 5th 1800
Sir I have read with attention, and duly considered, your letter of the 1st of this month, and all the papers enclosed with it, and am of opinion, that the public interest, and service requires that the proposed site and ore be purchased at the best terms, which can be obtained, and a national foundary for casting cannon, shot & Shells established, and I authorize you, in conjunction with the Secretary of the Navy, to execute this business as soon as possible
Secnd John Adams
Mr McHenry
Secretary of War
What has been done respecting this purchase, was done in conjunction with the Secretary of the Navy, whom I leave in this executive of the duties of the War Department — the business of which [undecipherable: hitherto] of course, upon your arrival at the seat of Government, turn over to you. To him I respectfully refer you, for the papers now made, and which shall be made by him in completing this purchase.
16. The Armory or manufactory for small arms at Springfield Massachusetts, an establishment of some contemplated [undecipherable], I had supposed was well conducted, and likely to become important to the public. The Superintendent employed there was constantly represented by respectable [undecipherable: people?], some of them in Congress, and I used acquainted with him, to be a man of integrity, industry, and attention to his trust, and the work done at the Armory, especially of late has been satisfactory. Apparent facts, and circumstances, have however recently evolved, which affect the character of the [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] Superintendent and discover improper practices, necessary to be checked. The
measures taken to investigate the facts and circumstances — by an inquiry to be made by respectable and intelligent gentlemen in the vicinity of Springfield — and above all in-fluence — will be seen — as approved by the President — on the books of the office. Perhaps immediate orders would be proper, to prevent in future apprentices to private persons, from being employed as workmen in the armory, borne on the muster rolls, and paid, for the benefit of their Masters. This practice would appear to lead to abuses.
15th. A lot of ground was purchased last summer near Philadelphia and on the river Schuylkill, for the purpose of another establishment, that of a military Laboratory, magazines for the safe keeping of all the Powder — military stores and other property under the controul of the War Department — and thought expedient to be deposited in the middle district of the Union. This measure, documents on file well evince, was undertaken after mature reflection, consultation with the Heads of Departments, and with their approbation
[strikethrough: approbation] three of the heads of Departments as well as that of the President. The necessary buildings were commenced, as soon as practicable after the purchase of the lot, and some of them are far advanced. In a short time, one or more of the stores will be ready to receive the articles they were intended to preserve. It will be necessary for the removal of the military articles, now stored in Philadelphia, to the new deposits; as they are progressively completed, and regulations will be indispensable, for the arrangement of the [strikethrough: [undecipherable] stores and] government of the persons employed as Laboratory Officers, Directors, Superintendants, Store keepers or in such other capacities as may be thought proper, as well as for the arrangement and preservation of the ammunition, small arms, cannon, cannon carriages — cloathing or materials therefor, and other articles when removed. The regulations mentioned will demand peculiar attention, if a good system is adopted. The [undecipherable: public?]
public will in a little time, not only attain an exemption from the payment of large sums in store rent [strikethrough: [undecipherable] [undecipherable]], but from the higher state of preservation in which every article will be kept, the very soon fully remunerated for the cost of the establishment.
Hitherto military articles when wanted have been to seek for, in a great number of private deposits — scattered throughout the U.S., consequently considerable expense has been incurred in rents and salaries to store keepers, and as the very extended superintendance required from the proper Officer, (the Superintendent of Military Stores) made it impossible, it proved in all cases be very particular — the property itself, has been much exposed to loss, or destruction, either from inattention in those charged with its care, or other causes.
I have long thought, and have directed the Superintendent accordingly — that beneficial results would arise from his visiting the
depositaries of military stores — once or [undecipherable: twice bound] at least once a year, on account of the certainty he would then have, that the different kinds of articles, were stored in buildings suitable for them respectively, and the superior vigilance that would be excited in the persons charged with their custody. The answer however has always been, that it was impracticable for him (the Superintendent) to leave the seat of Government. It may deserve consideration — whether it would not be right, to send a person of sufficient intelligence to visit these scattered depositaries, and report generally and specially from [undecipherable: written] actual inspection — the quantity, and kinds of articles in each, the present [undecipherable: abilings] of the store [undecipherable], the kinds, as well as the character and attention paid to their trust, by every person charged with the custody of military articles.
The [undecipherable: produce] [undecipherable: or exemption]
and widen, a lot from this being divided into so many different deposits & [undecipherable: contributions] from expense in rents — and a certainty of having our military articles well preserved and at all times prepared for use — it has been contemplated, to erect in addition to the one in question, in two or three other parts of the union mi-litary depots. Documents in the office will show the several places where it was thought best to establish them, having reference to the convenience and possible wants of the different States.
17. Mr Newman a young gentleman some three [strikethrough: times] introduced into the office of the Secretary of War, as a clerk, has been employed in the extra business, as translator of the French and German Languages. I had reserved a separate part of the appropriation for the whole number of Clerks, to compensate him for this service, which I request may be attended to. I would also suggest, that it was my intention
to increase his salary, which was at first fixed at [blank] dollars per annum, [undecipherable: having] found him faithful, diligent, unassuming, and possessed of talents sufficient, with a little more experience, to become extremely useful.
18. A young gentleman whose name I cannot at present recollect, [strikethrough: [undecipherable] by [undecipherable] recommended to [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: [undecipherable] [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: [undecipherable] on the recommendation of [undecipherable] by some time [undecipherable] [undecipherable]] [strikethrough: for] [undecipherable: on the recommendation of the Officer of the] a native of Virginia has been invited to [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] and agreed to fill a vacant clerkship in the office. From the specimens I have seen of his epistolary stile, and the account [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] [undecipherable: of his found] Talents I flatter myself he will [undecipherable: be found] and of [undecipherable] be deserving of the appointment [strikethrough: [undecipherable]] [undecipherable: His] salary, has been [undecipherable: fixed] for the [undecipherable: last year?] at 600 Dollars, [undecipherable: which] he has been promised.
His letter has been written in too much haste to be correct, and during my [undecipherable: deployments,] [strikethrough: ments,] in the current business of the office and those indispensable arrangements preparatory to my devoting myself of an official situation
Type
Autograph Letter Signed
Description
Letter from James McHenry, former Secretary of War, to his successor. McHenry details the state of the Department and points out what needs immediate action. He discusses the state of Indian affairs, the need for a military academy, the establishment of a factory for small arms near Harper's Ferry, and other matters.
Date
05/29/1800
Author
Recipient
Sent from
War Department
Repository
Collection
Document number
1800052940001
Page start
1
Notable persons
Samuel Dexter
James McHenry
Department of War
successor
Major General Hamilton
Major General Pinckney
Colonel Butler
infantry
Major Isaac Craig
sergeants
musicians
privates
Brigadier General Wilkinson
tailors
William Chancellor
Superintendent of Military Stores
North Western Indians
Chickasaw
Cherokee
Creek
Choctaw
Six Nations
President
John Adams
General George Washington
Paymaster General
contractors
officers
Congress
Artillerists and Engineers
Francis
engineer
laborers
Secretary of the Navy
Major Tousard
Newman
clerk
translator
Notable locations
War Department
Savannah
Knoxville, Tennessee
Natchez
Loftus Heights
Mississippi River
Pittsburgh
North Western Frontier
Philadelphia
Cincinnati
Chickasaw Bluff
Tellico Block House
Fort Wilkinson
Canadaigua
Oconee River
England
Baltimore
Potomac River
Harper's Ferry
Springfield
Schuylkill River
Virginia
Notable items
packet
measures
directions
orders
discharge
military articles
clothing
regiments
parcels
public store
monies
pay
act of congress
military stores
tents
material
buttons
white cloth
Indian stipends
treaties
factory
amelioration
condition of the Indians
Indian trading houses
condition
medals
bronze
silver
cattle
cultivation
land
domestic manufacture
spinning
weaving
public property
suits
cannon
inspect and prove cannon
settlement
accounts
contingent expenses
extra compensation
pay and emoluments
military academy
fortifications
small arms
fabrication of arms
canal
cannon foundry
ordnance
shot
armory
experiments
laboratory
expense
military articles
military depots
French language
German language

