[CONFIDENTIAL] Status of Military
Document 1800Discusses the power of the President to dismiss military officers and instances where such action is or has been appropriate. Also considers the attitudes of Congress towards the Army.
No human transcription currently available for this document.
This transcription was generated by machine using Anthropic's Claude Code (a mix of sonnet and opus models). It may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please verify against the document image. Learn more about our generative AI methodology.
[Docket notation, lower right of wrapper:] Aple 1st 1800 / Gen Armstrong
[Confidential] Philad. 1 Apl. 1800
Dear Sir.
you have well and strongly
[undecipherable: probable reading "express'd"] my opinion relative to theth circum-
:stances under which the President
may with propriety exercise his power
military
to dismiss officers from the service
[undecipherable] Innocent but one [undecipherable: probable reading "instance"]
in which this power was exercised by
us in this instance its propriety was really questioned
[undecipherable] because and I am persuaded
[undecipherable] at [a] dangerous [undecipherable] long established military
[undecipherable] a [undecipherable] [undecipherable] to it lay [on]
ought and [undecipherable] of the tempt of a
[undecipherable] assured [undecipherable]
military tribunal when it was thought
in the first instance
but ought alone to take cognizance of
[undecipherable] the fate of those offenders
military offences. I am persuaded that
if this power is frequently resorted to by the executive it will
the [undecipherable] [undecipherable] on
be denied and break down the military spirit
[undecipherable] would be productive
of and bring the army into a state of
debasement.
I have suggested to you in
my former letter how little certainty
there is of the present new army
being of long duration. This
suggestion rests upon the indisposition
discovered among a great many of
the federal members of Congress
[undecipherable] meet the expense for its support,
and a [undecipherable] policy influenced by
considerations of popularity. If we make
[undecipherable] is probable [undecipherable] the army and she
a treaty with France [undecipherable] to be
[undecipherable] break it [undecipherable] we [undecipherable] have the army
kept in to [undecipherable] they honored breaks
and if she should not break it, the giving
the body and if they do not [undecipherable]
necessary
it may be [undecipherable] to keep another
[undecipherable] [undecipherable] or oppose
[undecipherable] hostility.
Yours truly & affily.
W H [undecipherable]
I send you a letter from M'King just rec'd, that
our commissioners for France sailed [undecipherable]
on 21 Jany. for L'Orient and [that] no account
had been rec'd at London on the 3 Feby of
their arrival.
Type
Autograph Draft
Description
Discusses the power of the President to dismiss military officers and instances where such action is or has been appropriate. Also considers the attitudes of Congress towards the Army.
Date
04/01/1800
Author
Recipient
Sent from
Philadelphia
Collection
Document number
1800040100301
Page start
1
Notable persons
General Charles C Pinckney
James McHenry
President
officers
Congress
Mr. King
Commissioners
Notable locations
Philadelphia
France
Lison
London
Notable items
power
military tribunal
expense
policy
treaty
military offenses
military spirit

