Dispute Over Relative Importance of the Army & Navy, & Need for Congressional Approval of Military Supply System
Document 1799McHenry addresses a dispute between himself and the Secretary of the Navy, Benjamin Stoddert, regarding the relative importance of the army and navy. Also notes review of Hamilton's plan of military supply, and is of the opinion that its adoption requires no act of Congress. However, given the controversy on this matter, he will also submit it to the Secretaries of the Navy and State for their consideration.
No human transcription currently available for this document.
This transcription was generated by machine using Anthropic's Claude Code (a mix of sonnet and opus models). It may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please verify against the document image. Learn more about our generative AI methodology.
[I 118]
War Department, 12 July 1799
Sir.
I have had the honour to receive, this morning, your letter of the 7th of July inst.
It is very certain, Sir, that nothing was more remote from my thoughts, than to bring into comparison, the relative importance of the navy and army: and I believe, I shall never take the liberty, to call upon you to decide, what I flatter myself, it is impossible can ever happen, any dispute between Mr Stoddert and myself, or any other person on the subject.
It is strongly impressed upon my mind, that both army and navy establishments, are essential to the present and future interests and greatness of the United States. We must run the risk of their commanders, proving blessings or curses, from their genius, as all other nations have done before us.
According to the [undecipherable], or [undecipherable], I have viewed the plan, for supplying the army, it does not appear to me to require the sanction of any act of Congress. It is only a system, to execute powers actually given, or incidental to given powers. If it is otherwise, this department, and the Navy Department ever since their existence have been offending against law. I shall however consider the question and as closely as possible the plan, and submit it formally to the Secretary of the Treasury and secretary of State for their mature opinions.
With the greatest respect,
I have the honour to be Sir.
your most Obt
& hble St
John Adams James McHenry
President of the United States.
Type
Autograph Letter Signed
Description
McHenry addresses a dispute between himself and the Secretary of the Navy, Benjamin Stoddert, regarding the relative importance of the army and navy. Also notes review of Hamilton's plan of military supply, and is of the opinion that its adoption requires no act of Congress. However, given the controversy on this matter, he will also submit it to the Secretaries of the Navy and State for their consideration.
Date
07/12/1799
Author
Recipient
Sent from
War Department
Repository
Collection
Document number
1799071200501
Page start
1
Notable persons
John Adams
James McHenry
Navy
Army
Benjamin Stoddert
Notable locations
War Department
Notable items
act of Congress

