Doubts About Approving or Disapproving Sentences of Court Martials, Etc.
Document 1799Hamilton questions whether he has the authority to approve or disapprove sentences of Court Martials that have been instituted by officials other than himself.
100%
⇣No human transcription currently available for this document.
This transcription was generated by machine using Anthropic's Claude Code (a mix of sonnet and opus models). It may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please verify against the document image. Learn more about our generative AI methodology.
[Secy of War
Phila April 23]
[4y 136] [130]
Philadelphia April 23
1799
Sir,
Upon a careful inspection of the Articles of War I entertain doubts, whether I can act upon, by approving or [strikethrough: disapproving] [strikethrough: referred to me] sentences of Courts Martial [strikethrough: received] from the Department of War, in cases in which the Courts have been [strikethrough: ordered by] [strikethrough: that it] instituted by that Department through organs other than myself. As there is peculiar delicacy in inflicting punishments upon [undecipherable] authority, I shall be glad to be exempted from the embarrass-ment which references of the above mentioned kind [strikethrough: accumulated collected] will occasion. *
With the greatest respect
I have the honor to be
Yr Obt Sr
* I have written provisionally
Col Strong to abstain from
the execution of Martial law
at Detroit till further order, as I defer maturely
to reflect on the subject before a definitive—
[No 6248]
the Secy of War
Type
Autograph Draft Letter
Description
Hamilton questions whether he has the authority to approve or disapprove sentences of Court Martials that have been instituted by officials other than himself.
Date
04/23/1799
Author
Recipient
Sent from
War Department
Repository
Collection
Document number
1799042300001
Page start
1
Notable persons
Alexander Hamilton
James McHenry
Colonel [David] Strong
Notable locations
War Department
Notable items
careful inspection of the Articles of War
sentences of Court Martials
the courts
punishment
questionable authority
embarassment
execution of martial law at Detroit
organs other than myself

