Hagner's Statement: Confrontation Between Samuel Vance & William Simmons
Document 1799This is a formal statement by Peter Hagner regarding the confrontation between William Simmons and Captain Samuel Vance in which Vance accused Simmons of being a villain.
100%
⇣No human transcription currently available for this document.
This transcription was generated by machine using Anthropic's Claude Code (a mix of sonnet and opus models). It may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please verify against the document image. Learn more about our generative AI methodology.
No 1 [a Copy]
Statement by Mr Peter Hagner,
Principal Clerk in the Accountants
Office, of a conversation which
passed on the 20th February 1797.
between Capt Samuel Vance
& the Accountant of the Departmt
of War,
[19 41]
Capt Vance and Mr Simmons had some conversation relative to the claim of a Soldier for Clothing. Capt Vance asked Mr Simmons what answer he should give to the Soldier relative, to the Claim Mr Simmons observed that the original papers which had been presented some time ago to the Secy of War and to which there were some objections to the settlement there — must first be produced, and that the papers he now presented were insufficient — Captain Vance then said that either he — Mr Simmons or Capt. Vance must be a villain and that the insinuation relative to the papers produced was a rascally fib. Mr Simmons retorted, and observed that he Capt Vance had grossly insulted him in the execution of the duties of his Office, and he should make a proper representation thereof, and requested the Gentlemen present to note what passed. Several other epithets such as rascal &c. passed between them.
February 20th 1797 [undecipherable]
(Signed) Peter Hagner
Type
Copy of Signed Document
Description
This is a formal statement by Peter Hagner regarding the confrontation between William Simmons and Captain Samuel Vance in which Vance accused Simmons of being a villain.
Date
02/20/1799
Author
Repository
Collection
Document number
1799022015101
Note
Syrett listed this document in the Appendix to Vol. 22. Enclosed in McHenry to Hamilton, 02/22/1799.
Notable persons
Peter Hagner, Principal Clerk in the Accountant's Office
Captain Samuel Vance
William Simmons
Secretary of War [McHenry]
Notable items
soldier's claim for clothing
conversation
claim
original papers
objections to the settement
villain
insinuation
epithets
rascal

