Ascertaining the Truth Respecting General Smith
Document 1798Despite being afflicted with a vicious fever, McHenry has attempted to ascertain whether the sentiments attributed to General Smith have been correctly stated. Before he died, Captain Mitchell had presented his version of General Smith's conversation as had Mr. Bayard of the house of representatives of Wilmington, Delaware.
No human transcription currently available for this document.
This transcription was generated by machine using Anthropic's Claude Code (a mix of sonnet and opus models). It may contain errors or inaccuracies. Please verify against the document image. Learn more about our generative AI methodology.
Trenton 30th Aug. 1798
Dear Sir
* While I received your letter of the 30 of Aug. I was indisposed with a bilious fever, and [strikethrough: we visited le was not since a hard did] could not of course take any steps to assist you to discover whether [strikethrough: of the] the information given to you respecting the [strikethrough: conversation] sentiments, expressed by Gen Smith at the President's table [strikethrough: had] [strikethrough: received] [strikethrough: come] had been correctly related [strikethrough: to you]. In the mean while [strikethrough: —] [strikethrough: last] Cap Mitchell [strikethrough: did &] I found [strikethrough: hostler] on my recovery, that a certificate had been sent to you [strikethrough: stating by very] containing the [strikethrough: substance] of what Gen Smith had said on that occasion during my illness and as stated by Cap Mitchell to the [strikethrough: contemptible] men who subscribed it. [strikethrough: This] [strikethrough: Here was] Thus the business stood when the prevailing fever at Philadelphia [strikethrough: obliged] [strikethrough: forced] us to make before I had recovered. a very precipitate retirée. I have endeavoured by other testimonies, and since that time to ascertain the fact, [strikethrough: but when] [strikethrough: which I under] have understood, but yesterday evening that Mr Bayard of the House of representatives at Wilmington Delaware as was present at table with Gen Smith, and [strikethrough: he] & was so much struck with [strikethrough: the] my conversation and opinions [strikethrough: he expressed], that he mentioned them to several persons afterwards. [strikethrough: with much surprise and astonishment]
I shall drop him a line to day to [strikethrough: know] learn the truth and request him to make it known to you of [strikethrough: the] the fact in case you had also [strikethrough: be] it may be proper also that you should write to him.
Yours sincerely
Col. J E Howard.
---
Trenton 3 Sept. 1798
Dr Sir
Col Howard requested me [strikethrough: undecipherable] to the inclosed fragments of [strikethrough: News Newspaper strangely altered that had informed he] a letter [strikethrough: addressed to him that he was told that] [interlinear: that] Col. Howard [strikethrough: has represented the that] [interlinear: Gen] Smith at the President's table [strikethrough: and] said [strikethrough: had to have represented himself at the] President's table, [strikethrough: that] he wished our envoys had given the French the money they had demanded, and that Gen Smith denies the charge. Col Howard has earnestly requested me to give him [strikethrough: the] such informa-tion respecting the [strikethrough: General] language and conversation at [strikethrough: that] this occasion as may be in my power to obtain. Yesterday evening only I understood [strikethrough: that] you were of the party at the President's, and that struck with [strikethrough: the genera] the Gen's. [strikethrough: conversation] sentiments you had repeated what he had said to several gentlemen. If the fact is so, I request you [strikethrough: soon] to take the trouble to state the Gen's conversation to Col. Howard, [strikethrough: to make him] your testimony I consider of importance and I am certain you will not refuse it.
[strikethrough: *] I am Dr Sir with very great respect & esteem your obt St.
[Col. J. Howard — [undecipherable] conversation of Gen. Smith. 3 Sept. 1798]
Type
Draft Letter
Description
Despite being afflicted with a vicious fever, McHenry has attempted to ascertain whether the sentiments attributed to General Smith have been correctly stated. Before he died, Captain Mitchell had presented his version of General Smith's conversation as had Mr. Bayard of the house of representatives of Wilmington, Delaware.
Date
08/30/1798
Author
Recipient
Sent from
Trenton
Repository
Document number
1798083000001
Page start
1
Notable persons
James McHenry
James A. Bayard
Captain Mitchell
General Smith
Notable locations
Trenton
Wilmington, Delaware
Philadelphia
Notable items
his conversation and opinions
precipitate retreat
other testimonies
certificate
his illness

